Racial grievance mongers are sure to have their hackles up over the Trump administration’s new idea that could fundamentally transform food stamp programs forever.
Anyone who has ever had to stand in a checkout line behind someone who is using SNAP/food stamp government aid can attest to some of the garbage that people use their monthly giveaway for.
Let’s say that it’s not exactly the most nutritious variety of food and that is if they aren’t abusing the program to buy steaks and other pricey items or selling their entitlements on the sly to buy booze, cigarettes, drugs and rubbers.
On Tuesday, the announcement came that instead of simply sending money that the feds would be working with boxes of REAL and nutritional food somewhat similar to the meal kits provided by Blue Apron.
According to Budget Director Mick Mick Mulvaney, a part of the gubmint aid will come in the form of a box of actual staples that has been dubbed as “America’s Harvest Box.”
— CNBC Top Stories (@CNBCTopStories) February 13, 2018
- A proposed food delivery program would replace about half of food stamp benefits for households who qualify for the boxes.
- The plan would put the U.S. government directly in charge of what goes on the dinner plates of more than 16 million low-income households.
- Critics say the program would be inefficient and costly, and would end up reducing benefits for low-income families and communities.
The Trump administration is proposing replacing a portion of the federal food stamp program with actual boxes of food delivered to recipients’ front doors, putting the U.S. government directly in charge of what goes on the dinner plates of more than 16 million low-income households.
White House budget director Mick Mulvaney likened the model to that of the dominant meal-kit delivery service, Blue Apron, and called it one of the most “innovative” ideas in the president’s budget.
“I don’t want to steal somebody’s copyright,” Mulvaney told reporters Monday. “You actually receive the food instead of receive the cash.
The program would be a vast logistical undertaking for a federal bureaucracy that President Donald Trump has repeatedly criticized as unwieldy and wasteful. The White House said the new boxes would go to households qualifying for $90 or more per month in food stamps, representing about 81 percent of those participating in what is formally known as the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program. Currently, SNAP recipients can choose what they spend the money on while shopping at any approved retailer.
According to a summary of the proposal compiled by the Agriculture Department and obtained by CNBC, the boxes would replace about half of the current program’s cash benefits. All food would be grown domestically and include “shelf-stable” items such as juice, pasta, canned meat and beans. The USDA estimated it would save $129 billion over a decade, driven in part by the government’s unique purchasing power.
“It lowers the cost to us because we can buy prices at wholesale, whereas [beneficiaries] have to buy it at retail,” Mulvaney said. “It also makes sure they’re getting nutritious food. So we’re pretty excited about that.”
But the proposal drew swift opposition from many fronts – including the $840 billion supermarket industry, where food stamps drive 7.5 percent of sales, according to Customer Growth Partners. The firm estimated that Walmart alone reaps more than one-fifth of all food stamp sales.
Despite the playing of the race card and big companies like Walmart’s bitching this would seem to be one hell of a good idea for a number of reasons including:
- The poor can enjoy a much healthier diet which will contribute to fewer medical problems.
- Fewer medical problems will lessen the burden on the country’s health care providers.
- Having to cook the food is a good lesson in self-sufficiency unlike ripping open a bag of Cheetos.
- If people on assistance don’t like it they can simply get off of their lazy asses and go find jobs.
I would personally tend to agree with the great cartoonist Ben Garrison’s take on this one:
Thinking inside the box for America's food stamp program. When the food is free, the menu has only two choices: take it or leave it.https://t.co/5P6THjPmXP
— BenGarrison Cartoons (@GrrrGraphics) February 13, 2018
Here’s the USDA’s summary of the “America’s Harvest Box” proposal:
“USDA America’s Harvest Box is a bold, innovative approach to providing nutritious food to people who need assistance feeding themselves and their families – and all of it is home grown by American farmers and producers. It maintains the same level of food value as SNAP participants currently receive, provides states flexibility in administering the program, and is responsible to the taxpayers.” – Secretary Sonny Perdue
USDA America’s Harvest Box
- Under the USDA America’s Harvest Box proposal, all Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) participating households receiving $90 per month or more in benefits will receive a package of nutritious, 100-percent U.S. grown and produced food. Approximately 16.4 million households, or about 81 percent of SNAP households would be impacted by this proposal.
- The amount of food received per household would be scaled to the overall size of the household’s SNAP allotment, ultimately representing about half of their benefits. SNAP participants would receive domestically-sourced and produced food in lieu of a portion of their SNAP benefits.
- USDA would utilize a model similar to that currently used to distribute USDA Foods to other nutrition assistance programs to provide staple, shelf-stable foods (such as shelf-stable milk, juice, grains, ready-eat-cereals, pasta, peanut butter, beans, canned meat, poultry or fish, and canned fruits and vegetables) to SNAP households at approximately half the retail cost.
- This proposal creates a new approach to nutrition assistance that combines retail-based SNAP benefits with delivery of USDA America’s Harvest Boxes supporting the President’s leadership on Buy American. This proposal is cost-effective, enhances the integrity of SNAP, and provides for states’ flexibility in administration of the program.
- The remainder of the household’s benefits will still be provided via the current Electronic Benefit Transfer card.
- This proposal would save $129.2 billion over the ten-year period between Fiscal Year (FY) 2019 and FY 2028. This estimate accounts for about $2.5 billion annually in additional administrative funds for states.
- USDA currently purchases a wide variety of food for several nutrition assistance programs, including the National School Lunch Program, the Commodity Supplemental Food Program, The Emergency Food Assistance Program, and the Food Distribution Program on Indian Reservations.
- States will be given substantial flexibility to distribute these food benefits to participants. States can distribute these boxes through existing infrastructure, partnerships, and/or directly to residences through commercial and/or retail delivery services.
It’s not the complete reform that is necessary but a good step in the right direction.